Russian Doll Envelopes

Algorithms
Hard
Microsoft
132.9K views

You have a number of envelopes with widths and heights. Find the maximum number of envelopes you can 'Russian doll' one inside the other. This reduces to the Longest Increasing Subsequence (LIS) problem.

Why Interviewers Ask This

Microsoft asks this problem to evaluate a candidate's ability to decompose complex geometric constraints into standard algorithmic patterns. They specifically test if you can recognize that sorting by width transforms the problem into finding the Longest Increasing Subsequence on heights, while handling edge cases like equal dimensions correctly. This assesses optimization skills and deep understanding of time complexity trade-offs.

How to Answer This Question

1. Clarify Constraints: Immediately ask about input size limits (e.g., N up to 10^5) to determine if an O(N^2) or O(N log N) solution is required. Microsoft values precision in complexity analysis. 2. Sort Strategically: Explain your sorting logic clearly. Sort primarily by width ascending, but crucially, sort secondary by height descending for equal widths. This prevents nesting envelopes with identical widths, which is impossible. 3. Reduce to LIS: State that after sorting, the problem strictly becomes finding the Longest Increasing Subsequence of the height array. Justify why the width constraint is now implicitly satisfied. 4. Optimize Implementation: Detail the binary search approach for LIS using a dynamic array to achieve O(N log N) time complexity. Avoid the naive O(N^2) DP unless constraints are small. 5. Validate Edge Cases: Discuss handling empty inputs, single envelopes, and the specific behavior when widths are equal due to the reverse height sort.

Key Points to Cover

  • Explicitly identifying the reduction from 2D geometry to 1D LIS
  • Correctly explaining the dual-sort strategy (width asc, height desc)
  • Demonstrating knowledge of O(N log N) binary search optimization over O(N^2) DP
  • Articulating why strict inequality is required for nesting
  • Proactively addressing time complexity requirements typical of Microsoft interviews

Sample Answer

To solve the Russian Doll Envelopes problem efficiently, I first analyze the constraints. Since Microsoft often deals with large datasets, I assume we need better than O(N^2) performance. My approach involves two main phases: transformation and optimization. First, I will sort the envelopes. The key insight is that an envelope can only fit inside another if both its width and height are strictly smaller. To simplify this, I sort the envelopes by width in ascending order. However, for envelopes with the same width, I must sort their heights in descending order. This is critical because it ensures that when we process the list, we never accidentally pick two envelopes with the same width for our subsequence, as the larger height appears before the smaller one, breaking any potential increasing sequence. Once sorted, the problem reduces entirely to finding the Longest Increasing Subsequence (LIS) based solely on the height values. The width condition is automatically satisfied by our sorting strategy. For the LIS calculation, instead of using the standard O(N^2) dynamic programming approach, I will implement the patience sorting method using binary search. This allows us to maintain a list of 'tails' for increasing subsequences of various lengths. By iterating through the heights and using binary search to find the insertion point, we can build the longest chain in O(N log N) time. Finally, I will verify the solution against edge cases like zero-width envelopes or duplicate dimensions to ensure robustness.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Failing to sort heights in descending order for equal widths, leading to incorrect inclusion of non-nestable envelopes
  • Implementing the O(N^2) DP solution without considering that it may exceed time limits for large inputs
  • Ignoring the strict inequality requirement and allowing envelopes with equal width or height to nest
  • Not clarifying input constraints before choosing between brute force and optimized approaches

Practice This Question with AI

Answer this question orally or via text and get instant AI-powered feedback on your response quality, structure, and delivery.

Start Practicing

Related Interview Questions

Browse all 145 Algorithms questionsBrowse all 65 Microsoft questions